Key Takeaways
- A recruiter searches mainly among active candidates. A headhunter approaches employed professionals directly, often for senior or hard-to-find roles.
- The right choice depends on three factors: how rare the profile is, how urgent the need is and how confidential the search must be.
- At Fed Group, a permanent placement is billed on success only, at 15% to 25% of the annual salary. Direct search is usually priced higher.
- The two approaches work well together: a recruiter brings volume and speed, and a headhunter finds the rare profiles.
Headhunter vs recruiter: The differences at a glance
A recruiter fills a position from a pool of active candidates, found through job postings, a candidate database and their network. A headhunter maps the market and approaches employed professionals directly, often for senior or hard-to-find roles. The two bill differently and deliver at different speeds. This table sums up the eight criteria that matter when you decide.
| Criterion | Recruiter | Headhunter |
|---|---|---|
| Approach | Receives and screens applications, then taps their network | Maps the market and contacts targeted individuals directly |
| Target candidates | Mostly active or open to offers | Mostly passive and already employed |
| Types of roles | Common roles, high volume, urgent needs | Senior, strategic or hard-to-find roles |
| Fees | On success, as a % of annual salary (at Fed Group: 15% to 25%) | Higher % (often 25% to 33%), sometimes with a retainer |
| Typical timeline | 2 to 4 weeks | 4 to 8 weeks |
| Confidentiality | Possible, rarely critical | Often essential |
| Guarantee | Replacement guarantee | Replacement guarantee |
| When to choose | Profile available on the market, urgent need | Rare profile, strategic role, job posting with no results |
The recruiter: How they work and what profiles they find
A recruiter finds candidates among people who are actively looking or open to offers. That means applicants to job postings, profiles they’ve already met and their own network of contacts. A recruiter is well suited to common roles and urgent needs, because their pool is available right away.
The process is straightforward: briefing, pre-screening, interviews, then a shortlist. Our Fed IT team worked with a Montreal public agency whose systems administrator position became vacant again when the new hire didn’t show up on their first day. We presented three qualified candidates and filled the role in seven days. A recruiter does have one limit, though: if the right profile isn’t visible on the market, their pool isn’t enough anymore. That’s when headhunting takes over.
The headhunter: Direct approach and passive candidates
A headhunter targets professionals who already have a job, because top performers rarely browse job postings. They identify candidates, approach them directly and present the opportunity in a way that sparks interest in someone who wasn’t planning to move. This direct approach relies on market mapping: who holds a comparable role, at which companies and with what leadership signals.
It’s especially useful for senior roles. Our Fed Supply team worked on an import-export team lead position that had stayed vacant for more than a year after a failed first hire, because the person hired didn’t match the real needs on the ground. The profile had to combine three things: customs expertise, leadership and cultural fit. A role with all three requirements is rarely filled through a simple job posting.
Fees, timelines and guarantees: What really changes
Three things set a recruitment mandate apart from a search mandate: how you’re billed, how long it takes and what happens if the new hire doesn’t stay.
How are they paid?
There are two models. A retained search involves a payment at the start that commits the headhunter to the assignment, whether or not it succeeds. Contingency fees are paid only when someone is hired. In both cases, fees are calculated as a percentage of the annual salary.
At Fed Group, a permanent placement is billed at 15% to 25% of the annual salary, on success only and with no upfront fees. Direct search takes longer and is more targeted, so it’s usually priced higher, often between 25% and 33%. For a full breakdown, see our article on the cost of a recruitment agency.
How long does it take?
In our experience, a recruitment firm fills a position in two to four weeks. A search assignment usually takes four to eight, since the headhunter has to identify, approach and convince candidates.
Here are a few examples from our own mandates: a systems administrator position filled in seven days, an aerospace hire closed in 13 days, and a production supervisor role filled in one month after several months without results at another agency.
Guarantees, exclusivity and confidentiality
A replacement guarantee means the firm restarts the search if the new hire leaves within a set period. The length of that period varies from firm to firm, often three to six months.
An exclusive mandate gives the headhunter priority and the time to invest in the search. Confidentiality matters when you’re replacing someone who’s still in the role or don’t want to advertise the position. Headhunting lets you search discreetly.
Headhunter or recruiter: How to choose in 5 questions
Choose a headhunter when the profile is rare, strategic or most likely already employed. Choose a recruiter when the profile is available on the market and you need to move quickly. These five questions will help you decide:
- Is the role rare, senior or strategic? If so, lean toward headhunting.
- Is the right person probably already employed? Top performers rarely browse job postings.
- How urgent is the need? If you need someone within a few weeks, a recruiter with an active pool is the better bet.
- Does the replacement need to stay confidential? Headhunting offers a discreet approach.
- Have you already posted the job without results? An empty inbox doesn’t mean an empty market. Start by reviewing your approach with our tips for writing an attractive job posting. If the applications still don’t fit, switch to headhunting.
Headhunter, recruitment firm or staffing agency: What’s the difference?
A recruitment firm finds and screens candidates, and you then hire them directly. A staffing agency supplies workers to your business to meet a labour need, often a temporary one. A headhunter is a way of recruiting. They can work independently or within a firm.
In Quebec, a staffing agency must hold a CNESST licence to operate. To find the right partner, read our guide on how to choose a recruitment firm. We also cover the benefits of a staffing agency in a separate article.
Can you combine a headhunter and a recruiter?
Yes. The combination works well when your needs are mixed: the recruiter handles common roles and volume, and the headhunter takes care of hard-to-find profiles. Combining the two makes sense in a tight market. In the second quarter of 2026, the Institut de la statistique du Québec counted about 123,700 job vacancies in Quebec, for a vacancy rate of 3.1% (not seasonally adjusted). Our 2027 salary guides show that this tightness is targeted rather than widespread. In finance, competition remains strong for experienced CPAs, controllers and FP&A, payroll and tax specialists. In manufacturing engineering, the shortage mainly affects specialized technical skills (automation, control systems, PLC), with hiring timelines that can reach 65 days in R&D and engineering.
In this context, we use both levers: we stay in touch with candidates over time, and we can reach passive profiles. For example, we placed a technical support analyst again in three weeks. We had first placed her in 2021, so we already knew her file.
Our verdict: Which professional for which role?
Choose a recruiter for a profile that’s available on the market and an urgent need. Choose a headhunter for a rare or strategic profile, or for someone who’s already employed. Combine the two when your needs are mixed. If you’re unsure, start with how rare the profile is. We bring both approaches together across our four specialties (finance, IT, supply chain and manufacturing engineering), on success only and with no upfront fees. Tell us about your role and we’ll tell you which approach fits.
FAQ: Headhunters and recruiters
Is a headhunter a good fit for a mid-level or technical role?
Yes, if the profile is rare or hard to find through a job posting. A specialized technician, an engineer or a highly sought-after CPA can justify a direct approach. For a common role and an urgent need, a recruiter is often more effective.
Who pays the fees, the employer or the candidate?
The employer. At Fed Group, our support is free for candidates, and employers only pay when a hire succeeds, with no upfront fees.
What happens if the candidate gets a counteroffer from their current employer?
It’s a common risk with employed candidates, so keep a backup list ready. On a payroll master mandate, our Fed Finance team saw a candidate withdraw after receiving a counteroffer. We restarted the search right away from an active shortlist.
Can a headhunter approach a competitor’s employees?
In most cases, yes. According to Éducaloi, employees can look for a job without telling their employer. Unless they’ve signed a non-compete agreement, they can also go to work for a competitor, as long as they stay loyal and protect confidential information. Any agreements the targeted person has signed matter, so check with a legal advisor if you’re unsure.
What should I prepare before contacting a headhunter or a recruiter?
Four things: a job description that reflects the actual tasks, a salary range, your non-negotiable criteria and the people who will conduct the interviews. On one mandate our Fed Manutech team took over, a first placement had failed after a month because the actual tasks didn’t match the job description.